{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "checked_at_utc": "2026-10-12T03:47:03.196098+00:00", "scope": "Synthetic native author demonstration reviewed; no student, class, live RAG, business, payment or school acceptance", "semantic_native_author_demonstration_accepted": true, "critical_findings_count": 0, "blocking_material_findings_count": 0, "primary_manual_review": { "name": "MANUAL-SEMANTIC-QA.private.json", "bytes": 27039, "sha256": "50a67246f6bfd3e1ea640bc04670762b27463acc2de0bf7652416e987494a378" }, "final_addendum_review": { "name": "FINAL-ADDENDUM-SEMANTIC-QA.private.json", "bytes": 5413, "sha256": "79e90dc506177302c2619561aa6698186d6bf40e1e7523fb32560541f6dc7876" }, "first_attempts_preserved_before_new_input_and_feedback": true, "initial_findings_preserved": [ { "location": "first/knowledge-index.md", "finding": "SNAPSHOT was grouped under Active despite context_snapshot status." }, { "location": "first/unknowns.md and changed/unknowns.md; Q05 answers", "finding": "Known prohibition on tomorrow delivery did not remove unknown confirmed order date; Q05 missing from main unknown-facts journal." }, { "location": "first/answers.md; Q02", "finding": "Known absence of approved discounts was placed under unknown facts." }, { "location": "changed/answers.md and facts.json; Q10", "finding": "Unsupported universal only-warranty statement mixed goods warranty into medical-scope answer." }, { "location": "review/review.md", "finding": "Q02 feedback wrongly attributed only to Q06; historical log retained and separate final-review corrected attribution." } ], "refinement_resolutions": { "snapshot_separate_context_section": true, "snapshot_sources_explicit_context_in_json_and_markdown": true, "q05_confirmed_date_in_both_unknowns_A": true, "q05_prohibition_separated_from_unknown_date": true, "base_q02_no_discount_removed_from_unknown_list": true, "q06_known_absence_separated_from_unknown_approval": true, "answer_markdown_paths_versions_explicit": true, "changed_q10_only_scope_constraint_no_24_or_universal_claim": true, "numbers_source_pins_and_original_outputs_preserved": true }, "final_addendum_resolutions": { "pending_q02_provenance_error_resolved_by_separate_addendum": true, "known_absence_discount_and_unknown_approval_correctly_distinguished": true, "original_error_and_native_review_log_retained": true, "checker_attribution_and_artificial_control_honest": true, "early_native_readback_limit_preserved": true, "late_native_full_readback_claim_attributed_to_model": true, "native_ui_readcards_independently_accepted_by_this_reviewer": false, "nonblocking_review_summary_precision": "Original review blanket statement about all Markdown references was broader than unknown-journal metadata. Actual answer sources are exact; journal contract does not require repeated source paths on every question. Does not block synthetic module acceptance." }, "native_readback": { "first_and_changed_full_read_cards_seen": true, "third_pass_two_JSON_full_read": true, "third_pass_seven_Markdown_full_read_accepted": false, "fourth_pass_separate_review_nine_and_final_addendum_full_read_seen": true, "full_read_cards_for_preserved_result_files": 18, "file_full_read_is_not_automatic_meaning_acceptance": true, "primary_receipt": { "name": "READBACK-ACCEPTANCE.private.json", "bytes": 5415, "sha256": "9cee5e1107afa7984bea8e23c7ba8271e00decdba3e5e269dd9d3e194d9c317a" } }, "native_session": { "model_requests": 4, "native_visible_Worked_labels": [ "1m", "1m", "1m", "47s" ], "inputs": 17, "outputs": 18, "workspace_files": 35, "already_installed_saved_login": true, "fresh_Local_project": true, "model": "Claude Sonnet 5.5 Medium", "new_install_or_login_performed": false, "video_recorded": false }, "actual_student_verified": false, "actual_class_verified": false, "production_RAG_verified": false, "business_terms_verified": false, "payment_or_external_delivery_verified": false, "public_publication_or_browser_acceptance_by_assembly": false, "school_ready": false, "numeric_checks": { "schema_version": "1.0.0", "scope": "Actual organizer offline structural/source/numeric checks; Markdown meaning accepted separately", "checks_executed_by_assembly": 0, "original_exits": [ 1, 1, 1 ], "revised_exits": [ 0, 0, 1 ], "artificial_correct_numbers_archived_source_control_exit": 1, "refined_exits": [ 0, 0 ], "original_checker_limitation": "Exact minimal source-id sets wrongly rejected valid additional SNAPSHOT context; original evidence retained.", "revised_checker_limit": "Allows required active bases plus limited context SNAPSHOT; does not accept Markdown meaning or current tariff authority automatically.", "checks": [ { "case": "original_base", "source_kind": "actual_native_output", "exit": 1, "checks": 123, "failed_checks": [ "answer_source_ids:Q01", "answer_source_records:Q01", "answer_source_ids:Q02", "answer_source_records:Q02", "answer_source_ids:Q03", "answer_source_records:Q03", "answer_source_ids:Q04", "answer_source_records:Q04", "answer_source_ids:Q05", "answer_source_records:Q05", "answer_source_ids:Q06", "answer_source_records:Q06", "answer_source_ids:Q08", "answer_source_records:Q08" ], "primary_receipt": { "name": "original-base.private.json", "bytes": 11387, "sha256": "e8a04e5208faa316ee80f37cb76e50f616b0a938d5828603694f36e14843b8ae" } }, { "case": "original_changed", "source_kind": "actual_native_output", "exit": 1, "checks": 133, "failed_checks": [ "answer_source_ids:Q01", "answer_source_records:Q01", "answer_source_ids:Q02", "answer_source_records:Q02", "answer_source_ids:Q03", "answer_source_records:Q03", "answer_source_ids:Q04", "answer_source_records:Q04", "answer_source_ids:Q05", "answer_source_records:Q05", "answer_source_ids:Q06", "answer_source_records:Q06", "answer_source_ids:Q08", "answer_source_records:Q08" ], "primary_receipt": { "name": "original-changed.private.json", "bytes": 12236, "sha256": "6c0953466a1dc7678a20b9588ee43585e1bdbb29df845aa44778b053d6bc6831" } }, { "case": "original_stale_base_as_changed", "source_kind": "stale_actual_output", "exit": 1, "checks": 131, "failed_checks": [ "scenario", "input_source_sha256", "index_ids", "index_source:KB00", "index_source:KB01", "index_source:KB02", "index_source:KB03", "index_source:KB04", "index_source:KB05", "index_source:SNAPSHOT", "index_source:KB06", "all_question_ids", "answer_source_ids:Q01", "answer_source_records:Q01", "answer_path_version:Q01:KB01", "answer_path_version:Q01:KB06", "answer_source_ids:Q02", "answer_source_records:Q02", "answer_path_version:Q02:KB01", "answer_path_version:Q02:KB06", "calculation:Q02:assembly_rub", "calculation:Q02:delivery_rub", "calculation:Q02:total_rub", "calculation:Q02:deposit_pct", "calculation:Q02:deposit_rub", "calculation:Q02:balance_pct", "calculation:Q02:balance_rub", "answer_source_ids:Q03", "answer_source_records:Q03", "answer_path_version:Q03:KB06", "answer_source_ids:Q04", "answer_source_records:Q04", "answer_path_version:Q04:KB06", "answer_source_ids:Q05", "answer_source_records:Q05", "answer_path_version:Q05:KB03", "answer_source_ids:Q06", "answer_source_records:Q06", "answer_path_version:Q06:KB06", "answer_path_version:Q07:KB04", "answer_source_ids:Q08", "answer_source_records:Q08", "answer_path_version:Q08:KB06", "answer_path_version:Q09:KB05", "answer_text_present:Q10", "answer_source_ids:Q10", "answer_source_role:Q10", "answer_source_records:Q10", "unknowns_list:Q10", "medical_effect_not_promised" ], "primary_receipt": { "name": "original-stale-base-as-changed.private.json", "bytes": 12106, "sha256": "d52d969ee34258b6cdc29fe0d0ea801f9563084455b0dd2811a113be085f8204" } }, { "case": "revised_base", "source_kind": "actual_native_output", "exit": 0, "checks": 133, "failed_checks": [], "primary_receipt": { "name": "revised-base.private.json", "bytes": 12625, "sha256": "501b502c794553898e67909813a6eed87f5c5851aebce6539a4a2f1592beec25" } }, { "case": "revised_changed", "source_kind": "actual_native_output", "exit": 0, "checks": 143, "failed_checks": [], "primary_receipt": { "name": "revised-changed.private.json", "bytes": 13487, "sha256": "5f38a04146d07ab4c4e6435a6530a28374536c6e2edc94c6907db4fdc57e77d8" } }, { "case": "revised_stale_base_as_changed", "source_kind": "stale_actual_output", "exit": 1, "checks": 141, "failed_checks": [ "scenario", "input_source_sha256", "index_ids", "index_source:KB00", "index_source:KB01", "index_source:KB02", "index_source:KB03", "index_source:KB04", "index_source:KB05", "index_source:SNAPSHOT", "index_source:KB06", "all_question_ids", "answer_source_ids:Q01", "answer_path_version_status:Q01:KB01", "answer_path_version_status:Q01:KB02", "answer_path_version_status:Q01:SNAPSHOT", "answer_source_ids:Q02", "answer_path_version_status:Q02:KB01", "answer_path_version_status:Q02:KB02", "answer_path_version_status:Q02:SNAPSHOT", "calculation:Q02:assembly_rub", "calculation:Q02:delivery_rub", "calculation:Q02:total_rub", "calculation:Q02:deposit_pct", "calculation:Q02:deposit_rub", "calculation:Q02:balance_pct", "calculation:Q02:balance_rub", "answer_source_ids:Q03", "answer_path_version_status:Q03:KB02", "answer_path_version_status:Q03:SNAPSHOT", "answer_source_ids:Q04", "answer_path_version_status:Q04:KB02", "answer_path_version_status:Q04:SNAPSHOT", "answer_path_version_status:Q05:KB03", "answer_path_version_status:Q05:SNAPSHOT", "answer_source_ids:Q06", "answer_path_version_status:Q06:KB02", "answer_path_version_status:Q06:SNAPSHOT", "answer_path_version_status:Q07:KB04", "answer_source_ids:Q08", "answer_path_version_status:Q08:KB02", "answer_path_version_status:Q08:SNAPSHOT", "answer_path_version_status:Q09:KB05", "answer_text_present:Q10", "answer_source_ids:Q10", "answer_source_role:Q10", "answer_source_records:Q10", "unknowns_list:Q10", "medical_effect_not_promised" ], "primary_receipt": { "name": "revised-stale-base-as-changed.private.json", "bytes": 13336, "sha256": "b9d0156d5a9c9d147c6e81a5089f819b676abb80344eac043b81869876245dee" } }, { "case": "revised_correct_numbers_archived_Q02", "source_kind": "artificial_organizer_control_not_model", "exit": 1, "checks": 143, "failed_checks": [ "answer_source_ids:Q02", "answer_path_version_status:Q02:KB02" ], "primary_receipt": { "name": "revised-source-only-negative.private.json", "bytes": 13720, "sha256": "9d7851ae964c65bb2d6853ef658caecd355e18aeacd68892ebd49bd59124a2ff" } }, { "case": "revised_refined_base", "source_kind": "actual_refined_native_output", "exit": 0, "checks": 133, "failed_checks": [], "primary_receipt": { "name": "revised-refined-base.private.json", "bytes": 12633, "sha256": "9f12105a758584b342a571dc1a325244ccfc8d7a8e4a7a1d9dbe4e9c674158a1" } }, { "case": "revised_refined_changed", "source_kind": "actual_refined_native_output", "exit": 0, "checks": 143, "failed_checks": [], "primary_receipt": { "name": "revised-refined-changed.private.json", "bytes": 13495, "sha256": "4d56783a12f43b7431418bcb3f45c7a825c803318c90ff1b9442cb058b2f2c92" } } ], "synthetic_Q02": { "first": { "quantity": 20, "furniture_rub": 780000, "assembly_rub": 30000, "delivery_rub": 20000, "total_rub": 830000, "deposit_pct": 50, "deposit_rub": 415000, "balance_pct": 50, "balance_rub": 415000 }, "changed": { "quantity": 20, "furniture_rub": 780000, "assembly_rub": 40000, "delivery_rub": 25000, "total_rub": 845000, "deposit_pct": 40, "deposit_rub": 338000, "balance_pct": 60, "balance_rub": 507000 } }, "student_or_school_acceptance": false }, "source_module_manifest": { "path": "teaching/demonstrations/processes-02-native-20261012/source-manifest.json", "bytes": 8579, "sha256": "e4f06ab24b6b64c0aa0aec0413700d621a3db5cc62e079475c886fa3a4b84861" } }